The Philadelphia Story [1941]

The musical just does not compare - even though I like Frank in High Society - Grace Kelly could not spout enough of that slightly vinigared vim that KH does so well and Bing Crosby could not hope to replace Cary Grant's suave aire and understated humour. Much of the wit hinges upon this contrast and whether there will be a resolution!

- I could go on, but I would not like to spoil the movie for those who have not yet had the pleasure. If you like sophisticated, subtle humour - (at times quite gentle, but with an underlying theme that amplifies each quip), an outstanding script and skillful comic acting from all concerned, this is one for you.

Ella H.


One of the top 10 comedies of all time!   April 3, 2002
Peter Coats (London)
13 out of 16 found this review helpful

Unless you hate old films - this is from 1940 - then you can't fail to love this. It's fast, funny, sophisticated and sexy, with a fascinating menage a trois between spoiled society brat Katherine Hepburn, cynical ex-husband Cary Grant and inverted snob reporter Jimmy Stewart.

Each of the three protagonists is a strong and attractive character but the film never takes sides and we're left guessing until the last frames.

Not to be missed!

Not sure what the other top comedies should be, though.


Good screen adaptation of the play,   February 11, 2003
B. Chandler (Arlington, Texas)
Tracy Lords is getting married again. This time to a man who worked his way to the top instead of starting there. Dexter her first husband invites himself to the wedding and the wedding preparations. Also inviting their selves with a little blackmail to the wedding is a writer, and photographer, from a magazine of dubious reputation. Throw in a philandering father and a friendly uncle. We watch as they go through the motions and emotions of courting and re-evaluating their lives.
This is basically a comedy and yes it has all the actors and writers to make this a piece of cinematic art. However you will find it is just fun to watch.