Customer Reviews:
 If you've got a digital camera, you need to buy this February 10, 2007
Spuddy Spud (The Spuddery)
150 out of 152 found this review helpful
Photoshop Elements 5 is really two packages in one: a picture organiser, and a sophisticated photo editor.
Getting your pictures into Photoshop is a matter of plugging your memory card, or the camera itself, into your PC, and Photoshop imports them automatically. While doing this, it recognises similarities between pictures and makes `stacks' of similar looking pictures. This is not particularly successful because it fails to stack pictures of the same subject taken at different zoom levels, different orientations (portrait or landscape) and so on. Adobe perhaps needs to work on this. More successfully, Photoshop automatically recognises red eyes and corrects them before you even touch the pictures. You can also do this by hand once the pictures are in.
The importing software recognises most image formats, including RAW formats for most cameras. You probably won't need to use the picture-grabbing software that came with your camera.
Once the pictures are in the organiser, you have many ways of viewing them, by filename / folder location, date and time, and even by geographic location, since Photoshop lets you pin your pictures to a world map. A nice touch for globetrotters or international agents. The organizer also lets you `tag' pictures with key words like people's names, type of subject, and so on. Useful but not essential, unless you have tons of pictures that you want to search by picture content as opposed to just the date they were taken. Additionally, a couple of clicks will bring up the picture info showing the camera setting you used like aperture size, shutter speed, white balance settings and suchlike.
The really impressive and magical part of Photoshop is the magnificent photo editor, for which no hyperbole would be unjustified. From the organizer, you can call up two editing screens - the quick fix editor, and the full editor.
Most basic corrections can be made via the quick fix screen. These include contrast, sharpness, lighting (darken highlights, lighten shadows), and colour (saturation, colour temperature, green vs. pink tint). Editing is achieved very, very simply using slider controls. You can undo every step in your edit, or revert to the original picture in a single click. There is also a `smart fix' control that will do the whole lot for you in one go. Despite my scepticism, this function works very well indeed. The great majority of pictures can be improved on the quick fix screen in a matter of seconds.
The most enchanting part of Photoshop though is the full editor. Here, tons of point and click tools will apply blur, enrich colours in selected parts of pictures, smooth out blemishes (a VERY clever and useful tool), and level skewed horizons. The menus are mind bogglingly deep, with each option having several sub-options. You can fine-tune colour, lighting and contrast to your hearts content using very accessible colour / brightness curves, and even perk up skin tones. Don't like that picture of you in a green shirt? Change it to a blue shirt, or any other colour you like. Photoshop makes these alterations amazingly convincingly if you take a bit of time over your pictures. It also makes crisp black-and-white pictures with presets for portraits, landscapes, newspaper-style greyscales, etc. All these presets, like most everything else in Photoshop, can be tweaked by the user.
The most fun is to be had in the `Filters' menu. This includes a rich range of photographic filters such as solid colours and gradients, which can be fine-tuned in terms of the tint and density. The only filter you will need to attach to you camera will be a polarizer, for which there is no simulator in Photoshop. There are also many brush, texture, blur, smudge and other artistic and darkroom effects to make your pictures look like they're out of a magazine.
My absolute favourite has to be the Camera Distortion filter, which lets you correct curvature at the edge of the picture when you've used a wide lens, and pinch-in the `bulge' you sometimes get with zooms. This is a splendidly simple process: you tilt the picture to straighten uprights, adjust the bulge / pincushion effect, lighten the lens vignette effect if it's visible, re-crop the white bits out of the picture, and the job's done, all with a few sweeps of the mouse.
After all this playing about, Photoshop will clean up the speckles, noise and jpeg artefacts that sneak in when you take digital pictures. Far from looking phoney or `touched up' after using Photoshop, the pictures look more natural, more like the eye saw the scene, than they did when they came out of the camera. Unless of course you WANT your pictures to look like brass rubbings viewed through frosted glass, which it can also do!
Editing pictures is easy and absorbing with Photoshop. It enhances your enjoyment of your pictures and the whole process of photography, as well as perhaps making you more aware of how to compose and frame your shots for the next shoot. It is dangerously easy to spend hours tinkering with your pictures on Photoshop!
And still there's more. You can make slide shows or interactive albums and burn them to video disks or e-mail them to your friends. You can even get prints if you want (how quaint).
The only omission I've found so far is that there's no easy way to calibrate your monitor brightness and colours to the prints you get from your selected printer / developer. While this can be done using the monitor hardware settings, it's a pain to do it like this, and it surely wouldn't have been too much trouble for Adobe to have included some screen brightness and colour setting options. At present the only way I can compensate for this is to make the on-screen images a tad brighter, because the prints come out a bit darker. Also, printed documentation is sparse, although the Help pages are extensive and user-friendly.
Overall though, this is a superb package. It's comprehensive, very easy to use, and good value for money given the huge number of things it can do. If you've got a digital camera, you need this software.
Drkroom on your computer December 17, 2006
M. Donaghy (Scotland)
112 out of 117 found this review helpful
Everything I wanted in photo editing plus a lot more.
I was looking for something to replicate a black and white darkroom on the computer.
How this matches my requirements: lets you select an area and burn in or dodge the exposure.
What else does it do? - everything you can imagine probably, and then some.
Main features I have discovered so far:
You have all the effects of a box of Cokin filters, including b&w and gradients.
Correct just about every fault, except camera shake.
I can't really list everything here. Suffice to say, whatever you are looking for, it will probably have it.
It had crossec my mind to buy Photoshop CS2, but saved a fortune by buying this instead.
Get it, use it, you won't regret it ... March 19, 2007
R.E.Viewer (Overseas)
91 out of 93 found this review helpful
... I am essentially a nerdy techy, but not necessarily massively savvy with photo editing software. Until recently I have always 'fought' with the more complex versions of Photoshop (CS, CS2), achieving mediocre results.
A few days ago I tried Elements 5.
Wow ... what took me an hour to achieve elsewhere, I can do here in a matter of minutes (and it looks better with Elements than my attempts with CS2).
Be warned though ... this is not noddyland stuff though, in order to use it properly, you still have to spend some time with Elements, read and watch some tutorials, learn a little about layers, and the like.
It obviously does not have the power of Adobe Photoshop CS2, and if you are a hardcore digi-photo/graphic bod, then stick with that, but if you are a bit liek me and want to turn out reasonable results fairly quickly, then save your pennies and get this.
[...]
 For the price, close to perfect May 21, 2007
J. A. Keightley (UK)
62 out of 63 found this review helpful
An ex pro photographer, digital for 6 years, I have tried many editing software programs.
Up till now for the price Paintshop Pro was hard to beat, it still is very good software for the price.
My first trip into Elements and I am impressed, the browser is probably worth the money on it's own, but you have a full blown editor that can do practically everything you are likely to wish for. It's not perfect, because it can be slow to work/respond at times, running on a Pentium 3.0ghz with 1gb ram, there are times it's a little frustrating, but that is probably it's only achilles heel.
One big advantage is the amount of information, books, magazines, articles on the internet that all relate to photoshop elements, helping you to learn even more neat editing tips and tricks.
I would recomend this software to any digital camera user, just make sure your computer is not too old and slow or you may find you are tapping your fingers too much.
Elements 5 VS Photoshop CS3 August 22, 2007
Craig Thomas (UK)
57 out of 60 found this review helpful
I bought Elements 5 upon release last year, I have now upgraded to CS3. Elements 5 is far simpler to use than CS3 and rather oddly comes with a decent handbook where CS3 comes with nothing. Elements is easy to use straight from the box where CS3 requires a huge amount of knowledge. Elements has tools that I can't seem to find in CS3 such as straighten tool, magic extractor and adjust colour for skin tone.
For your average user (I am a professional) Elements batch processing is simple where CS3 requires pre-saved actions by the user. For the price, there is no comparison however the advantages of CS3 will only be appreciated in high-end work e.g. colour profiling, pre-press work and for those seriously into re-touching.
For the time being, I will be doing most of my work with Elements, however with CS3 classroom book by the Adobe Creative Team on order I hope to eventually learn CS3 and use it for all of my editing.
One thing I will recommend, is looking into purchasing an older version of Photoshop and upgrading as this may be cheaper.
Conclusion, if you are a high-end user CS3 is definitely for you, if not enjoy Elements 5 it will certainly do you. I have had none of the "problems" mentioned by other reviewers except my machine at 256MB of RAM sometimes struggles, however CS3 needs 512MB of RAM and a new machine was purchased for that.
|
